Bay Shore

Mamas Santina
201 Orinoco Dr Brightwaters, NY 11718
631-665-7880
Mamas Santina’s is a pizza place that is in Brightwaters Village.

It is a hot spot for lunch and during the school year many students relax and eat a piece of pizza. Mamas is family owed that has great prices and go along with their great food.

Fat Fish Wine Bar and Bistro
28 Cottage Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
631-666-2899
Fat Fish located near the Bay Shore Marina

Fat Fish Bar & Bistro is open year round! Take in the breathtaking views of the bay while enjoying the cuisine of executive chef and proprietor Brian Valdini. The Fat Fish is more of an upscale restaurant.

Cool Water Grill
25 Bayview Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
631-206-0420
Cool Water Grill is located by the Bay Shore Marina.

Cool Water is open for lunch and dinner. It is under the same ownership as the Fat Fish.

Captain Bill’s
133 Ocean Ave Bay Shore, NY 110706

This restaurant in located right on the water. Captain Bill’s in upscale and is more of a catering place for large parties.

John Thomas Inne
91 Howells Rd Brightwaters, NY 11718
631-66620
Peter Pan Diner
854 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, NY 11076
Forum Diner
315 W Main St. Bay Shore, NY 11706
Coyles’ Homemade Ice Cream
75 Howells Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706

Food

Leigo’s
631-665-1606

Leigo’s is a deli that is run out of the owner’s house. They make the best sandwiches; it is so worth the wait for the sandwich. You can get a foot long sandwich and a drink for under $5. Leigo’s isn’t the cleanest place but people at know about Leigo’s still go there for lunch.